My Husband Will Regret The Day He Chose Her Chapter 22
The lawsuit Eleanor filed against Alexander went to trial in her absence.
The trial was held in Paris. Alexander had rushed over from southern France; he sat in the defendant’s seat, looking haggard.
The public gallery was packed—Richard, Alexander’s, former shareholders of Sterling Enterprises, and reporters who had caught wind of the news.
The judge called the court to order.
Eleanor’s attorney, a French woman in her forties, stood up to present the case.
Her tone was calm, her logic clear, as she presented the evidence piece by piece:
Eleanor and Alexander’s marriage certificate and divorce decree.
Oliver’s birth and death certificates.
The kidnappers’ confessions and the bank transfer records.
And—the complete audio recording of the conversation between Natalie and the kidnappers’ middleman.
When the recording was played in court, an uproar erupted in the gallery.
Murphy covered her face and began to cry, while Richard closed his eyes, striking his cane heavily against the floor.
Alexander kept his head down, his shoulders trembling slightly.
“This is only circumstantial evidence.”
His lawyer attempted to argue, “My client had no knowledge of…”
“Then what about these?”
The female lawyer brought out another stack of documents.
—Evidence of Natalie bribing a doctor to forge medical records.
—Lab reports showing she had put allergens in Oliver’s food.
—Transcripts of her sessions with a therapist before the kidnapping: “He said I’m the one he loves the most, that he only has a responsibility to Eleanor… As long as that child disappears, we can be together…”
Alexander’s head snapped up, staring at those documents in disbelief.
He never knew Natalie had done all this.
“Furthermore,” the lawyer looked at the judge, “my client has instructed me to play one final video.”
The courtroom screen lit up.
The footage showed the living room of The Sterling Estate. The timestamp indicated it was a year ago—one month before Oliver passed away.
On screen, Natalie sat on the sofa while five-year-old Oliver played with building blocks nearby.
“Oliver,” Natalie waved gently. “Come here, Auntie has some candy for you.”
Oliver shook his head. “Mommy says I can’t eat candy. It’ll make my teeth hurt.”
“Just one. It’ll be fine.”
Natalie pulled a piece of chocolate from her pocket. “Look, your daddy brought this back from abroad. It’s really yummy.”
Oliver hesitated for a moment before taking it. “Thank you, Auntie.”
“Good boy, Oliver.”
Natalie stroked his head and suddenly asked, “Oliver, do you like Auntie?”
“I do.”
“Then… what if Auntie became your new mommy? Would you like that?”
Oliver froze, whispering, “I have a mommy…”
“But your mommy doesn’t like your daddy.”
Natalie sighed. “She’s always fighting with your daddy, and it makes him sad.
If Auntie becomes your new mommy, your daddy will be happy, and you’ll get a little brother to play with. Wouldn’t that be nice?”
Oliver kept his head down, taking a long time before saying, “I want Daddy to be happy…”
“That’s right.”
Natalie smiled and hugged him. “Oliver is the sweetest boy.
Come on, let’s have another piece of candy…”
The video ended there.
The courtroom was dead silent.
Alexander sat there like a stone statue.
He remembered that during that time, Oliver did constantly complain about toothaches.
When Eleanor took him to the dentist, he had even thought she was making a fuss over nothing.
He remembered how Oliver used to be so clingy for a while, always asking:
“Daddy, are you and Mommy going to separate?”
How had he answered back then?
He had said:
“Stay out of grown-up matters.”
It turned out that, out of his sight, his son had endured so much.
It turned out that Natalie, the woman he thought was innocent and kind, had been eroding his family all along.
“Defendant,” the judge looked at Alexander, “do you have anything else to say?”
Alexander slowly stood up.
He looked at the empty plaintiff’s seat—that was Eleanor’s place.
She didn’t even want to show up.
“I…” he began, his voice broken. “I plead guilty.”
Gasps erupted from the gallery.
“I admit that I indirectly caused the death of Oliver.”
Alexander spoke word by word, tears falling silently. “I was negligent, I was blind, I listened to lies… I failed as a husband, and I failed as a father.”
“I don’t ask for leniency, I only ask…” He looked at the judge. “I only ask you to tell me where she is… I just want to prostrate myself and apologize to her face to face…”
The judge fell silent for a moment:
“The plaintiff has explicitly stated that she does not wish to see you.”
Alexander closed his eyes.
The last shred of hope was extinguished.
A week later, the verdict came down:
Although Alexander did not directly participate in the kidnapping and murder, his gross negligence and indulgence indirectly led to Oliver’s death. He was held liable for civil compensation and ordered to pay Eleanor one million yuan for emotional distress.
At the same time, the court ordered him to issue a formal public apology to Eleanor through the media within three months.
In the eyes of the public, this sentence was far too light.
But to Alexander, that paper verdict was a pillar of shame nailed into his soul.
For the rest of his life, he would live bearing the sin of “killing his own son.”
And this was exactly what he deserved.
